College Hockey Insider by Mike McMahon
College Hockey Insider by Mike McMahon
HomePodcastChatLeaderboardAbout
Sign in

Mailbag: Thoughts on an expanded NCAA Tournament, Colgate’s struggles, AHA bids and more

Plus: ECAC launching a Hall of Fame, BC is retiring Johnny Gaudreau’s number, injury updates and more

Mike McMahon's avatar
Mike McMahon
Nov 19∙ Paid

On Tuesday’s episode of our College Hockey Rundown podcast, we talked about the potential for NCAA tournament expansion, and I mentioned the 24-team bracket with home-site and neutral-site games that I developed last season. In today’s mailbag, a new subscriber asked me to explain it, so I did.

Also in the mailbag:

  • Can Division III teams recruit CHL players?

  • An update on Félix Lacerte’s departure from Vermont.

  • Why is Colgate struggling?

  • With Army off to such a strong start, can Atlantic Hockey America be a two-bid league?

  • Why didn’t I include Detroit on my Frozen Four wish list?

Today’s newsletter also includes:

  • UMD is hopeful Max Plante will be back soon.

  • Boston College will retire Johnny Gaudreau’s number, and a statue honoring him and his brother, Matthew Gaudreau, will be dedicated in New Jersey.

  • Injury news from Boston University.

  • Michigan’s new athletic director has hockey connections.

  • New sponsorship deals at Alaska Anchorage and Robert Morris.

  • The ECAC is launching a Hall of Fame.

  • The latest commitments, including a 4.5-star forward to Notre Dame.


Mailbag: Thoughts on an expanded NCAA Tournament, Colgate’s struggles, AHA bids and more

Q. On the podcast this week you talked about a 24-team NCAA tournament and what that proposal could look like and you said that you wrote about it. I’m a new subscriber. Can you refresh for us newbies what that format would look like under your proposal? — Matt G.

Sure! Here’s my proposal.

Week 1 (campus sites): Teams 1-12 host teams 13-24 in single-elimination games.

Week 2 (regionals): That leaves 12 teams, so my proposal calls for two six-team regionals. To make it easier to follow, I’ll use the top 12 teams in last season’s NPI to show how the schedule would work.

Regional No. 1

  • Byes: (1) Michigan, (3) Michigan State

  • Thursday: (8) Minnesota Duluth vs. (9) Penn State

  • Friday: (6) Dartmouth vs. (11) Cornell

  • Saturday: Michigan vs. Thursday’s winner

  • Sunday: Michigan State vs. Friday’s winner

Regional No. 2

  • Byes: (2) North Dakota, (4) Western Michigan

  • Thursday: (7) Providence vs. (10) Quinnipiac

  • Friday: (5) Denver vs. (12) Wisconsin

  • Saturday: North Dakota vs. Thursday’s winner

  • Sunday: Western Michigan vs. Friday’s winner

The Saturday and Sunday winners at each site advance to the Frozen Four.

User's avatar

Continue reading this post for free, courtesy of Mike McMahon.

Or purchase a paid subscription.
College Hockey Insider by Mike McMahon

Mike McMahon reacts and analyzes the latest news around college hockey while bringing readers insider notes from sources around the country.

  • About
  • Archive
  • Recommendations
  • Sitemap
© 2026 Mike McMahon · Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for writing, podcasting, and media founders.